Laura F. Deutsch

freelance writer

A MYSTERY AT THE DOHANY SYNAGOGUE

The Dohany Synagogue (also known as “The Great Synagogue”) is Europe’s largest. It is located on the corner of Budapest’s Jewish ghetto. (Theodore Herzl grew up next door.) A non-Jewish, Viennese architect named Ludwig Forster built the synagogue in the 1850’s. He used a Moorish-revival style that he believed paid tribute to the history of the Jewish people. Certain “church-like” elements (including domes, round stained-glass windows, and a large organ) were added to reflect the philosophy of Nealog Jews who wanted to blend into Hungarian society without sacrificing Jewish values. The synagogue contains seats for approximately 3,000 people including two balconies for women.

The Arrow Cross bombed the synagogue in 1939; the Siege of Budapest at the war’s end caused further damage. Restoration, which began in 1991 and was partially funded by Estee Lauder, took seven years to complete. The area around the synagogue now includes other significant sites such as a Holocaust Museum and the Raoul Wallenberg Park with a magnificent metal sculpture of a weeping willow tree. Each metal leaf contains the names of Holocaust victims. A ghetto wall has been re-created from brick and topped with barbed wire. The Dohany Synagogue complex is certainly worth seeing if one is ever in Budapest.

So, what is the mystery?

I did some research before our visit and learned the Germans used this beautiful synagogue as headquarters for the German radio and a horse stable. Additionally in 1944, Adolf Eichmann established his Budapest office in the women’s balcony behind a large stained-glass window called “The Rose Window.” Here he made arrangements to deport approximately half a million Hungarian Jews to their deaths. However, I found other sources indicating  Eichmann never maintained an office in the synagogue. He was headquartered first in the Hotel Majestic and then in a villa formerly owned by a Jew. So, was his office at the synagogue or not?

I asked our tour guide about these different accounts, and she was quick to state Eichmann never had an office at The Dohany Synagogue. She insisted this was a rumor stemming “from false depictions in the cinema.”

However, my husband and I stopped to listen to another English-speaking tour guide who was adamant Eichmann’s office was in the synagogue behind The Rose Window. She told us people deny Eichmann’s presence because of a fear Jews won’t come to worship if they know his office overlooked the main level of the synagogue. She suggested it is better to believe Eichmann’s office was never there. When my husband said it is better to know the truth, she asked if we were Jewish. Before moving on to her next tour group, she said: “If you knew Eichmann had been up there behind The Rose Window, would you want to come for sheedooyeff?”

Sheedooyeff?

We returned to our hotel, and with some local assistance, realized that what we heard as “sheedooyeff” was really “Zsido ujev” which means “Jewish New Year” in Hungarian. My husband and I considered the woman’s question. Would we celebrate The New Year at the Dohany Synagogue knowing it had served as an office for one of the greatest mass murderers the world has ever known?

Of course, this was a hypothetical question since we were returning to Massachusetts. And I confess the idea of praying with the ghost of Eichmann sitting up on the women’s balcony behind a desk filled with papers ordering Jews to their deaths is completely ghoulish. However, if we rule out all the synagogues the Nazis destroyed, desecrated and used for alternate purposes (such as places to gather Jews before deportation), few untouched synagogues remain in Europe. Where would Jews go to worship?

But there is a concern beyond the practical.

During Rosh Hashanah, we inwardly evaluate and determine what needs to be improved and re-made so we can be our best selves. We also contemplate our relationship with God. But Rosh Hashanah is not just about solitary reflection. We pray together, and during The High Holy Days we celebrate the Jewish community that has always been essential to Jewish life. By using The Dohany Synagogue as an actual house of worship, we recognize the importance of looking forward. We pay tribute to the strength of the Jewish community that continues to survive despite the best efforts of others to wipe us off the planet. (Even concentration camps inmates found ways to secretly form their own communities for prayer despite being surrounded by unfathomable horrors.) What more important time to show our courage and solidarity as a people than at the High Holidays?

I’m still not sure where Eichmann’s office was; perhaps solving this mystery doesn’t matter so much in the end. What I am sure of is we must never allow vestiges of hatred to keep us away from a house of worship or from our own community. The Dohany Synagogue (and the accompanying complex) is truly magnificent. But its value lies beyond the architectural details, plaques and exhibits. It is a synagogue that retains vitality only if used. We should never forget history and hardship. But it is more important we use our faith and values to live as Jews.

This article was originally published in The Jewish Advocate on September 25, 2015.

laura-f-deutsch